{
  "record_type": "Retrospective summary of the retained press-shop visual-quality review",
  "review_date": "2026-09-21",
  "delivery_version": "0.3",
  "scope": "Representative authored press-shop demonstration, subsequently revised; not a real plant capture",
  "author_action": "The author challenged the claimed visual quality after delivery.",
  "review_method": "Inspection of decoded delivered video frames and original RTX images. This was a separate review, not a Scene Acceptance judge run.",
  "findings": [
    "The delivered video had correct 1920 by 1080 dimensions but did not meet the requested convincing photorealism.",
    "The capture chain lost fine surface and text detail. Near-matching source and video frames were not exact pose matches.",
    "Sharper RTX stills retained simplified machinery and surface detail; a cleaner encode alone would not resolve those scene limitations."
  ],
  "image": {
    "file": "/images/scene-acceptance-packs/press-shop-v03-rtx-tooling.png",
    "original_file": "tooling.png",
    "sha256": "21f401eb75cd3e97e02a96202fa4ffe419f7dd7c785f0ceea6318c30224d9b2f",
    "bytes": 1504264,
    "resolution": [
      1920,
      1080
    ],
    "renderer": "NVIDIA RTX path tracing through ovrtx and ovstage",
    "evidence": "Original image matches the retained GPU archive and preservation manifests. The dated quality review identifies this separate tooling still as path-traced.",
    "transformations": "None; original PNG bytes copied.",
    "does_not_establish": "This still is not a video compression comparison, a later repaired scene or proof of photorealism."
  },
  "review_source_sha256": "92edbecb22f1b4a1299f1afdf8c9752357ec983b953cd853de6105898e7a35d6",
  "texture_credit": {
    "asset": "concrete_floor_02",
    "creator": "Poly Haven",
    "license": "CC0",
    "source": "https://polyhaven.com/a/concrete_floor_02"
  },
  "current_judge_detected_this": false
}